Mirror Therapy

 

Thangapappa. B1* and Devakirubai. E1

1Associate Professor, Sacred Heart Nursing College, Madurai

2Professor, Sacred Heart Nursing College, Madurai

*Corresponding Author Email: thangapappas@gmail.com.

 

ABSTRACT:

This article reviews the use of mirror therapy for treating many neurological disorders like phantom limb pain, chronic regional pain syndrome and stroke paralysis.  Mirror visual feed back activates the mirror neurons to unlearn the learned paralysis / learned pain. This simple, non invasive, cost effective modality replaced the way we approach damage to the brain. This noteworthy modality will flood the faith and hope among amputees and stroke survivors.

 

KEYWORDS: Mirror therapy – mirror neurons – phantom limb pain – chronic regional pain syndrome – stroke paralysis.

 


INTRODUCTION:

“When I look in the mirror, I see strength, learned lessons, and pride in myself”.

 

Viewing oneself through a mirror can evoke peculiar experiences.  This has led to a novel modality called mirror therapy for a variety of pain and disability states especially involving the hands and feet, in particular phantom limb pain, stroke, complex regional pain syndrome and focal dystonia.  Graded motor imagery is a sequential process of rehabilitation which provides essentially a series of brain exercises. The process is made up of (i) laterality reconstruction (ii) motor imagery and (iii) mirror therapy. Hence mirror therapy is the final stage of graded motor imagery.  It is a simple, non invasive modality used for rehabilitation of the above mentioned conditions. Mirror theory is based on the evidence that action observation activates the same motor areas of the brain as action execution.

 

Definition of Mirror Therapy:

Mirror therapy is ground breaking non invasive treatment, in which the mirror is used to present the reverse image of a body part to the brain.  This therapy was unveiled by Vilayanur S. Ramachandran and Rogers in 1996.  Under this therapy, a patient is allowed to feel the imaginary movement of the removed / paralysed body part behaving as normal body through a mirror.  The mirror image of the normal body part helps reorganize and integrate the mismatch between proprioception and visual feedback of the removed / paralysed body2.

              

Figure: 1 – Represents Mirror Therapy

 

Equipment used in Mirror Therapy:

Mirror Box:

In this mirror therapy  mirror box is used, which is a box with one mirror in the centre where on each side of it, hands are placed in a manner that the affected limb is kept covered always and the unaffected limb is kept on the other side whose reflection can be seen on the mirror2.

  

Figure: 2   

   

Figure: 3

 

Figure: 2 and 3 – Represents Mirror Box

 

Biological basis of mirror therapy – Mirror Neurons:

Our brain consists of billions of neurons and trillions of connections. Rizzolatti3 used a MIRROR NEURON to explain the fundamentals of a mirror therapy.  At first, a mirror neuron was found in the monkey premotor cortex and later Rossi discovered that humans also have similar mirror neuron system in the frontal and parietal lobes. These areas are rich in motor command neurons each of which fires to orchestrate a sequence of muscle twitches to produce simple skilled movements.

 

These mirror neurons may be important for understanding the actions of other people, and for learning new skills by imitation.

 

The use of mirror visual feedback in restoring brain function:

The mirror visual feedback paves the way for a paradigm shift in the way we approach neurological disorders.  Instead of resulting entirely from irreversible damage to specialized brain modules, some of them may arise from short term functional shifts that are potentially reversible. The mirror visual feedback is used in restoring brain function especially for stroke, phantom limb and complex regional pain syndrome.

 

1. Mirror Therapy and Stroke:

 

Unlearned

 

Learned Paralysis

 
                                  Mirror Therapy

 

 


                                     

 

Stroke paralysis results form actual permanent damage to the internal capsule and also from a form of learned paralysis.  This learned paralysis can be potentially unlearned by using a mirror.  An additional possibility is that the lesions are not always complete, there may be residue of mirror neurons that have survived but are dormant or whose activity is inhibited and does not reach threshold (motor areas may have become temporarily inactive as a result of the same mechanism as learned paralysis – a failure of visual feedback to close the loop).  Mirror visual feedback might owe part of its efficacy to stimulate these neurons, thus providing the visual input to revive the motor neurons. 

 

Stroke

 

Incomplete lesions

 
 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


   

 

 

 

 

 


               

 

Revive Motor Neurons

Figure: 4 – Schematic representation of the Mirror Therapy and Stroke

 

 

 

 

Mirror Therapy and Phantom Limb Pain:

When an arm or leg is amputated, many patients continue to experience the vivid presence of the limb, hence the evocative term ‘Phantom limb’ coined by Mitchell (1872). Large proportion of amputees experience severe intractable pain in their phantom limb that can persist for years after amputation. The pain can be burning, cramping, crushing or lancinating. It can be intermittent or unrelenting, severely compromising the patient’s life.

 

Ramachandran predicted the learned paralysis theory of phantom limbs. Phantom limb pains may be induced by a conflict between visual feedback and proprioceptive representations of the amputated limb.  Thus illusion or imagery movement of the amputated limb might alleviate phantom limb pain.  Pain relief associated with mirror therapy may be due to the activation of mirror neurons in the hemisphere of the brain that is contra lateral to the amputated limb. These neurons fire when a person either performs an action or observes another person performing an action.

Amputations

 

 

 

Mismatch between visual feedback and proprioception of the amputated limb

 

 

Severe, burning, cramping, crushing, lancinating pain, phantom limp pain (Vivid presence of the limb)

 

 

Learned pain

 

 


Learned immobilization

 

 

Through a mirror visual feedback

 

 

Activation of mirror neurons

 

 


Mirror neurons fire and start to imitate the action performance through visual illusion

 

 

 

Learned pain, learned immobilization                      Unlearned

 

 


Patient is free from phantom limb pain

 

Figure: 5 – Schematic representation of the Mirror Therapy and phantom limb pain

 

 

 

Mirror Therapy and Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy or Complex Regional Pain Syndrome:

This syndrome was first described by the physician Mitchell who described the phantom limbs (Mitchell 1864). The hallmark of the disorder is the persistence – indeed progressive increase in pain, swelling and inflammation in a limb long after the inciting injury has gone, despite the trivial nature of the original injury and despite the absence of any current infection or tissue damage.

 

 

 

 

Original inflammation

 

 

Any attempt to move the arm would cause severe pain

 

 


Corollary discharge from these very attempts get linked in a Hebbian memories

 

 


Though inflammation is not there, even an accidental signal to limb evokes or amplifies the associated memories of learned pain learned immobilization

 

 


MIRROR VISUAL FEEDBACK

 

 


Conveys the visual illusion

 

 


Painful arm is moving in response to motor commands

 

 


Un learning of learned pain and learned immobilization

 

 

 

Figure: 6 – Schematic representation of the Mirror Therapy and Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy or Complex Regional Pain Syndrome

 

 

 

 

Other uses of Mirror Therapy:

Mirror Therapy is used in

·        Focal dystonias

·        Dejerrine Roussy syndrome (thalamic pain)

·        Trigeminal neuralgia

·        Parkinsons’ disease

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Oval: More SensitiveHow to Perform a Mirror Therapy:

                                                                                                                                                                          

 

 

 

 

 


Inside the Box

Outside the Box

·      Keep the hand still resting in a comfortable position

 

·      Keep the hand still resting

·      Keep the hand resting with a slight bend in the fingers

·      Bend the wrist up and down with in the limit of pain

·      Oppose the fingers and gently touch together

·      Make a fist, pushing into some discomfort, then repeat in time with the hand out side the box.

·      Rotate the hand and wrist fully.

·      Move both hands fully and include some extra tasks e.g. squeezing a ball or writing.

·   Keep the hand still / resting in the same position as the hand in the box-just observe the reflection

·   Rotate the hand

·   Make a fist then slow relax; repeat

·   Bend the wrist through its full range of movement.

·   Oppose the fingers with same force together

·   Make a fist and sequecze in repetition

 

·   Copy the hand in the box through a full range of movement.

·   Copy the hand in the box.

                                                                                                                                                                          

Oval: Less sensitive                                                                                                                                                                            

 

 

Clinical studies of Mirror Therapy:

Ramachandran et al, (1995)

 

MacLachlan et al. (2004)

Chan et al. (2007)

Sumitani et al. (2008)

 

 

Damall (2009)

Altschuler et al. (1999)

Sathian et al. (2000)

 

Stevens and Stoykov (2003)

 

Stevens and Stoykov (2004)

Sutbeyaz et al (2007)

 

Yavuzer et al. (2008)

 

McCabe et al (2003b)

Karmarkar and Lieberman (2006)

Vladimir Tichelaar et al. (2007)

Selles et al. (2008)

Sumitani et al. (2008)

 

 

Rosen and Lundborg (2005)

Altschuler and Hu (2008)

Series of cases of mirror therapy for phantom limb pain and immobility in upper limb amputees.

Case study of mirror therapy for a lower limb amputee with phantom pain

Randomized controlled trial of mirror therapy for phantom limb pain

Series of cases examining the effect to mirror visual feedback on qualitative aspects of pain patients with phantom limb pain after amputation, brachial plexus or other nerve injury.

Case study of mirror therapy for phantom limb pain

Pilot study of mirror therapy for hemiparesis following stroke.

Case study of mirror therapy in a patient with hemiparesis and sensory loss following stroke

Two case studies of mirror therapy for patients with hemiparesis following stroke.

Case study of mirror therapy in hemiparesis following stroke.

Randomized controlled trial of mirror therapy for lower extremity hemiparesis following stroke.

Randomized controlled trial of mirror therapy for lower extremity hemiparesis following stroke.

Controlled pilot study of mirror therapy for CRPS

Case study of mirror therapy for pain in CRPS

Case study of mirror therapy for CRPS

Case study of mirror therapy for CRPS

Series of cases examining the effect to mirror visual feedback on qualitative aspects of pain patients with phantom limb pain after amputation, brachial plexus or other nerve injury.

Mirror therapy for hand surgery patients with nerve injuries

Mirror therapy for patient after a wrist fracture with good passive, but no active range of motion.

 

 


CONCLUSION:

Loss of body part                                 Loss of hope

Paralysed limb                                     Paralysed faith

Unbearable pain                                  Unwilling to live

 

Thousands of years it was considered that damage to the brain is permanent and irreversible.  This non expensive, simple modality force brain to stop telling the body that the limb is in pain / paralyzed.  Mirror therapy activates the mirror neuron to fire and initiates the action performed.  “A small spark can ignite thousands of light”.  Mirror therapy is like a small spark to ignite thousands of hope among stroke survivors and amputees.

REFERENCES:

1.       Jennifer Gibson, Mirror, Mirror on the wall-stroke rehabilitation. Journal of Neuroscience Neurology. 2008.

2.       When is mirror therapy used a review available from Innovateus, innovation and information for sustainable living, pubmed-indexed for MEDLINE.

3.       Giacomo Rizzolatti and Maddalena Fabbri Destro, Mirror Neurons, Scholarpedia 3(1): 2005.

4.       Ramachandran VS and Altschuler EL, The use of visual feedback in particular mirror visual feedback in restoring brain function. Brain a Journal of Neurology, 132, 1693-1710.

5.       Sae Young Kim and Yun Young Kim, Mirror therapy for phantom limb pain, The Korean journal of pain. 2012: 254-272

6.       G. Lorimer Moseley, AlbertoGallace and Charles Spence, Is mirror therapy all it is cracked up to be? Current evidence and future direction. Pain 138, 2008: 7-10.

 

 

 

Received on 17.09.2014           Modified on 20.09.2014

Accepted on 28.09.2014           © A&V Publication all right reserved

Int. J. Adv. Nur. Management 2(3): July-Sept.,2014; Page 185-188